Famed Neurosurgeon Help - Possible Bug?

[Nala Skye]

Any ideas on how to actually get this? I had even managed to get 75% respect, with like...26 Neurosurgeon points o.o (pull knife out of fox in the begining, help sick child at end, sheild child from burning building). Someone told me to make sure Monsters and humans pretty much hate each other completely, butI still haven't been able to get it. Any ideas/help?

Edit: No one can seem to get this. I thought maybe it was just me. I've been playing this for so long, maybe I'm just doing the same things over and over. I had my 3 year old son randomly pick choices. I've had my Boyfriend play around with it a few times. Even my boyfriend's best friend has played. Is this a bug that just needs fixed? Some info would be nice :( I'd really love to get this last achievment.

[Happy.Cerberus]

I suspect that your honesty needs to be low.

I now have trouble finding the neurosurgeon options although I got almost all of them on the first play-through. Just can't seem to find any of them.

EDIT: Hmm, apparently, low honesty doesn't do the trick. I just managed to get >30 neurosurgeon, >75 respect with <30 honesty and didn't get the option.

[Nala Skye]

Exactly >< I don't know if this is some kind of bug, where it just doesn't show up anymore, or what. :( Everyone else I've talked to said they've been stuck on this one too.

[Caybar]

+1 ...i also can't figure this one out. I tried what other people have suggested with the high respect and what not but everytime it doesnt pop up ever.

[Gunnlæifsson]

Okay, I was able to get this achievement. I had high cleverness and kindness, zero-low honesty, performed some of the neurosurgeon adventures, zero-low bravery and ferocity. Also, I think it's important that I talked to the spine doctor and asked about ascending and dissolving before attending the test, then perform his "fern" task. humans and monsters must hate each other as well. My respect was just at 39 btw.

[Caybar]

Thanks xRsalc4do...Got it with:
0 Bravery, 91 Clever, 9 Ferocity, 3 Honesty, 100 Kindness, 41 respect, 5% monsters, 16% humans, 28 neurosurgeon points (did 3), did fern task, fought them, got the trigger. Thanks a lot. Definitely need respect below 50 because I had all of that + 50 respect and it would not trigger.

[amossong]

Thanks xRsalc4do... also got it with:
9 Bravery, 100 Clever, 15 Ferocity, 55 Honesty, 100 Kindness, 48 respect, 16% monsters, 17% humans and 18 neurosurgeon points (did 1 in the first village and 1 as an elder, got the rest after the trigger), did fern task, fought them. Then went with the neurosurgeon. I'm not sure about the stats but agree that you need low respect below 50.

[Darth Cannabis]

judging from the below 50 respect the key factor is other monsters not liking you, so you go hide with the humans.

[Nala Skye]

Awesome! Thanks for the tips! Going to try this right away :) Wish me luck!
Edit: Yup. This worked perfectly! Thanks guys!!!

[Drunk Rooster]

Thank you so much. This was very helpful.

[Bread]

how do you get to that path 0_0

[Veristeron]

Still not able to achieve this one, can somebody provide tutorial for this one maybe?

[Stexred]

thanks i got it too

[Jedo]

Got mine with these stats:

http://i.imgur.com/Tg0koPc.jpg

same as the others..

- low respect (guessing it's below 50%)
- did the first area's neurosurgeon event (it's a arm on a sling icon: pull the knife out)
- I had high stats for bravery, cleverness, and kindness to increas my chances for passing the elder test
- did the next neurosurgeon event (same icon, journey to carmen, nurse the human)
- low opinion for monsters and humans (doesn't have to be 0%)
- convince them to fight (they won't listen because you have low respect)
- the spine doctor will offer a chance for you to be saved (choose to go with her)

[White]

I just want to add that sometimes when you're a Monsterling, the first neurosurgeon event (with the pulling out the knife from one of the Elders) doesn't always appear. I'm not sure if those 3 points make or break your chances of getting the Neurosurgeon ending though, but maybe the game checks if you did that event or not.
In any case, if you notice that when you're a Monsterling and you don't see an event represented with an arm in a sling, you might want to restart.

From my own experience, the Neurosurgeon event after you've ascended to Elder status always appears.

[Jedo]

Początkowo opublikowane przez White Rider:

I just want to add that sometimes when you're a Monsterling, the first neurosurgeon event (with the pulling out the knife from one of the Elders) doesn't always appear. I'm not sure if those 3 points make or break your chances of getting the Neurosurgeon ending though, but maybe the game checks if you did that event or not.
In any case, if you notice that when you're a Monsterling and you don't see an event represented with an arm in a sling, you might want to restart.

From my own experience, the Neurosurgeon event after you've ascended to Elder status always appears.

It appears whenever you pick 'actions and attitude' instead of 'thoughts and words'. In my last 6 playthroughs that's what I picked and it appeared everytime. :o