Steam for Linux > 综合讨论 > 主题详情
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月16日下午1:33
Is Wine (PlayonLinux) safe, just for Steam?
Hi everyone. I'm thinking on running Steam via PlayonLinux since only one game I have is ported so far. I would just run Steam, no programs, nothing else, just Steam.

My question would be if Wine is an open door for network attacks.

NOTE: I'd put the wine folder into another user account with no privileges.
正在显示第 1 - 15 条,共 27 条留言
< >
sounds like a wooosh 2013年1月16日下午1:47 
Security is always relative, right? - So: What kind of security do you aim for?

I personally run Steam with Wine here in my normal user account (firewall not touched so far for multiplayer - that might change though). - So your setup looks already safer than mine…

What kind of dangers again do you try to minimize?
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月16日下午1:58 
I will not run any .exe files except for Steam itself. I will use Wine just to play Steam games. But I'm affraid WIne is an open door for network attacks, something like a friend getting my IP and trying to invade my machine
`][`arron: Linux 2013年1月16日下午3:31 
not much of a friend...
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月16日下午3:31 
引用自 Tarron Linux
not much of a friend...
Why?
ThOR27 2013年1月16日下午4:17 
Wine doesn't open any doors on your computer, if someones attacks you is probably a security issue on steam rather than wine (most probably)..
Anyway any kind of software you run can be a potential security issue if some kind of a exploitable bug is found...
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月16日下午4:19 
So I should be safe just using Wine to play Steam games? =)
cement_head 2013年1月16日下午4:43 
yes
towo01 2013年1月16日下午10:43 
I will not run any .exe files except for Steam itself.
Sure, you will, every game is an exe-file.
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月16日下午11:58 
引用自 towo01
I will not run any .exe files except for Steam itself.
Sure, you will, every game is an exe-file.
----Except Steam----
gutigen o) 2013年1月17日上午12:50 
Well, even Windows is safe if you use properly :)

WINE itself doesn't open any doors and applications run by WINE has no root access. Tbh as long as you do not use WINE for pirated apps it will be fine and if you think that WINE behavior is suspicious (or specific app), you can always kill the process easly, which very often is not possible under Windows. Also you can remove all links from WINE prefix to your HOME folder to improve the feeling of being secure (there is an option in WINETRICKS for that) :)
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月17日上午1:00 
I'm still processing this idea. But thanks for the info regarding security =)
craigchambers 2013年1月17日上午5:10 
引用自 towo01
I will not run any .exe files except for Steam itself.
Sure, you will, every game is an exe-file.
----Except Steam----

I'm not sure if you're labouring under some sort of misconception, but the Windows version of Steam is 'steam.exe'

Given that you have a working Linux Steam install, why would you want to install the Windows version under WINE (or PlaysOnLinux) if you don't actually intend to install any games?

As towo01 pointed out any game is an executable. If you have installed any games via Steam under WINE, all that Steam does is provider a launcher for the executable
i.e. You run an executable for the game if you launch it from Steam - this is true regardless of platform.

As to security with WINE - if you'd be happy running a game from steam under Windows, you should be happy running it under WINE.
Hirage 2013年1月17日上午5:22 
引用自 craigchambers
引用自 towo01
I will not run any .exe files except for Steam itself.
Sure, you will, every game is an exe-file.
----Except Steam----

I'm not sure if you're labouring under some sort of misconception, but the Windows version of Steam is 'steam.exe'

Given that you have a working Linux Steam install, why would you want to install the Windows version under WINE (or PlaysOnLinux) if you don't actually intend to install any games?

As towo01 pointed out any game is an executable. If you have installed any games via Steam under WINE, all that Steam does is provider a launcher for the executable
i.e. You run an executable for the game if you launch it from Steam - this is true regardless of platform.

As to security with WINE - if you'd be happy running a game from steam under Windows, you should be happy running it under WINE.
Cool down, it's just a misunderstanding.
Junior s2 Camila 2013年1月17日上午7:53 
OF COURSE I know Steam is a .exe and it's games also have .exe files, but i guess It's hard to say ---JUST STEAM--- without having some folks asking "you know steam is a .exe too, right?"

Come on people.
最后由 Junior s2 Camila 编辑于; 2013年1月17日上午7:59
Kiori 2013年1月17日下午1:26 
Wine doesnt have a proper 'system32' or the whole windows bundle with it, so all in all anything that targets windows(malware i mean) should -not- work with it. But thats relative to an extent.
I would roughly say wine is safer than windows, it runs on linux you know.
正在显示第 1 - 15 条,共 27 条留言
< >
每页显示数: 15 30 50
发帖日期: 2013年1月16日下午1:33
帖子数: 27