Roche or Iorveth's path, which is better and more appropriate in terms of lore wise?

[mrjstnly]

Title is it, answer thanks.

[DeathWantsMore]

Both are equally interesting.

[mrjstnly]

Originally posted by DeathWantsMore:

Both are equally interesting.

Ok but I am wondering which geralt would choose.

[DeathWantsMore]

Roche path probably more believable for Geralt to choose, just my opinion.

[mrjstnly]

Ahh ok, thanks.

[EolSunder]

Do them both. Play a game as a swordsman and pick one path, then play as maybe a mage and pick the other. You'll have a nice time with the different builds and the different choice paths are nice to break up a 2nd playthrough.

You get the idea.

[mrjstnly]

Thanks

[FreshwaterAU]

I sort of thought Iorveth's pass made more sense for Geralt as I read the books, plus he's being asked by zoltan, which I think makes it a big deal. Plus the ultimate goal of Act 2 seems like something Geralt would be a fan of. That said I mean you cant go wrong.

[Noidburg]

After playing both I much prefer Ioverth's path. You should play both to get the big picture of the whole story though.

[Manperor of Mankind]

While both paths are wildly different but equally enjoyable, I personally think Geralt would pick Iorweth's path, Freshwater has some good points there.

[therussmeister]

I preferred Iorveth's path, but...what EolSunder said.

[Furiey]

Which is better seems to be down to personal preference. It is definitely worth playing both as the story/information you gain is different and will give you two sides to the story.

[Manperor of Mankind]

Concerning Witcher3...can you actually meet Iorveth or Saskia?

I quite miss the grumpy elven bastard. :D

[Furiey]

Neither Iorveth or Saskia appear in Witcher 3 whereas Roche does, so in that regard the Roche storyline in W2 follows through better.

[mrjstnly]

Thank you all for the help, I appreciate it. By the way I chose Iorveth's path :)

[Crying Hamster]

take iorveths path its better for ur first playtrough, i played all 3 games completly and it doesnt matter what u do do roche he always forgives u