Guns of Icarus Online > General Discussions > トピックの詳細
tannersan 2月7日 16時38分
What were the critics smoking?
I need some o dat
1-12 / 12 のコメントを表示
< >
Urz 2月7日 17時44分 
As I understand it, most of the Metacritic reviews were based on buggy pre-release versions of the game.
[Muse] Bubbles  [開発者] 2月7日 20時19分 
Yeah there's definitely that. But the important thing is to us to keep improving and deliver better and better experiences for everyone. Not too hung up on Metacritics (well, I do gripe about it sometimes), can't really dwell on it.
Fendelphi 2月8日 0時30分 
As Urz said, the reviews were made back in 2012, where the game obviously had less content and was a less smooth experience.
The score does not match the current game at all.

Not only that, some of the reviews seems to be written from a one hour experience, without playing with a few friends. Some feels more like a "first impressions" rather than a full review, and that is just not ok, when meta-critic scores kind of sticks(and they do have an impact on buying habits).

MUSE, you should get new reviewers to look at your game, to get a review that actually matches with what the current game has to offer.
[Muse] Bubbles  [開発者] 2月8日 5時33分 
@Fendelphi, yeah noted. With Metacritics, like Urz pointed out, there were a couple of reviews that were done before the game was released, when it was still early beta or late alpha, and there was another review where the reviewer spent very little time in game and factual errors being corrected in comments by another editor who did spend more time in game. But with Metacritic, this type of things can happen, and we just have to not dwell on it and move on. I do really appreciate the IGN review though. Without us knowing, Nathan spent over a week in game, and he really knew how to play it, and his critique (both the positives and negatives) was really fair and on point. But with any review of an online multiplayer game that is supported, what was over a year ago is not the same as what is today. This is another drawback of Metacritic and release reviews in general. But yeah, once co-op is at a state where we feel good enough to show to journalists, we'll try to get more reviewers to review game, and the reason why we will likely have to wait til co-op is ready is because journalists usually have a lot of games to get through, and it would be better use of their time to show them something new and different.

Thanks a lot for the support! Really really appreciate this! Howard
最近の変更は[Muse] Bubblesが行いました; 2月8日 5時34分
Fendelphi 2月8日 6時42分 
Also a thing to remember is that the user score is 8.8(which is pretty good).

Of the lower scoring reviews, some of them were due to not being able to play the game(technical issues), or because they reviewed their experience with some bad eggs instead of the game in its entirety("I didnt like the people that I played with, so the game is bad").

Anyway, your game is great, and you are doing a great job in listening to the community AND keeping true to your own visions and ideas. There is no other game out there like this one.
[Muse] Bubbles  [開発者] 2月8日 7時52分 
Thanks a lot Fendelphi! The important thing for us is to just keep taking feedback and improving on what you guys get to enjoy.
Fireeye 2月8日 14時07分 
I'd say someone just forgot to bribe the critics. Otherwise this would automatically be 10/10 GOTYAY
ZaSpecialist 2月8日 17時11分 
I don't think people trust metacritics anyway, maybe just the new generation players that are mostly potatos. The game imo deserves easy an 88 in the present stage. True players always test a game and don't trust some "professional" reviewers. All the stupid generic low skill games that hold your hand get an almost perfect score nowadays, and that tells me that those reviewers have no clue how to really examine a game. Pretty graphics and some scripted animations...so cool.

PS User score is really 8.8, I swear I didn't know that :D
最近の変更はZaSpecialistが行いました; 2月8日 17時13分
B'oh | ShadowFighter88 2月11日 13時36分 
That and, in both film and games, what the critics rate well doesn't always match what the public thinks of it. How many films got panned by critics but either went on to become cult classics or just be really popular despite what the reviews said? And the same thing's happened to games. Better to look at the user scores for a game if you're going to use Metacritic at all.
Mike 2月11日 16時49分 
i wish the devs added a ship that looked like a sandwich it would be pointless but funny.
Sandwhich on the port bow! open fire
Erheller 2月11日 17時30分 
ZaSpecialist の投稿を引用:
PS User score is really 8.8, I swear I didn't know that :D

Related[tvtropes.org]
KT_Extinction 2月11日 19時59分 
THIS GAME IS AWESOME. THE FACT THAT MORE PEOPLE DON'T PLAY IT BLOWS MY MIND.

STEAMPUNK AIRSHIPS. PEW PEW. CLUNK CLUNK.

Seriously though, this game is great. Can't wait to see more adventure mode stuff!
1-12 / 12 のコメントを表示
< >
ページ毎: 15 30 50
投稿日: 2月7日 16時38分
投稿数: 12