But of course 2012년 10월 5일 오후 11시 32분
A little bit of plagiarism or just a great tribute?
Am i the only one who noticed the HUGE similarities between this song from S&S http://youtu.be/sIOZsfA9gt0 and this http://youtu.be/XXS3XZwPaEk (2003)?
15개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
Pineapple 2012년 10월 6일 오후 10시 24분 
It's either a nod to Metroid, or just a coincidence. I'd say the first is more likely. I can see a lot of indie developers slipping in references to classic games. I wouldn't rule out the second, though. They do sound alike, especially at the little melody parts, but most of both the songs is just a beat with some bass. I realized recently that the music from the new Hobbit movie sounds kind of like part of the score from Braveheart, so there's an example.
Pineapple님이 마지막으로 수정; 2012년 10월 6일 오후 10시 24분
Ap2000 2012년 10월 9일 오후 12시 48분 
Unlikely.
But of course 2012년 10월 10일 오전 11시 12분 
Pineapple님이 먼저 게시:
It's either a nod to Metroid, or just a coincidence. I'd say the first is more likely. I can see a lot of indie developers slipping in references to classic games. I wouldn't rule out the second, though. They do sound alike, especially at the little melody parts

I agree, i'm pretty sure that Jim Guthrie made a reference to the Metroid song. Btw, there are some other big references to Zelda series in the game.
Ap2000 2012년 10월 10일 오후 12시 00분 
Vomit Storm님이 먼저 게시:

Btw, there are some other big references to Zelda series in the game.

No way, Sherlock ! lol
But of course 2012년 10월 10일 오후 12시 02분 
Ap2000님이 먼저 게시:
Vomit Storm님이 먼저 게시:

Btw, there are some other big references to Zelda series in the game.

No way, Sherlock ! lol




Ap2000님이 먼저 게시:
Unlikely.

U mad and deaf bro? Hahaha!!
Ap2000 2012년 10월 10일 오후 12시 55분 
Yes, clearly.
Baggins_of_41 2012년 10월 15일 오후 4시 06분 
I don't think there's any intentional tribute here. The beats and melodies are just too dissimilar. If it were an intentional tribute, you'd expect more in common between the melody at 0:37 in S&S and 3:22 in MP, for example. Not necessarily an exact copy, mind- just enough of a similarity between the notes to unambiguously invoke memories of the older melody.

The closest similarity I can hear between the two is the mechanical/animalistic sound effects woven into the bass line. Even that is more a similarity in stylistic choice than a direct copy of the sounds involved.

If there's any link between the two, I'd guess it was more of a subconscious inspiration than any intentional reference. (A fairly common occurrence among music composers of any genre.) It's even possible both pieces share a third, older piece that inspired both of them.
♔ King ThirdSketch 2012년 11월 27일 오전 1시 45분 
Honestly, I don't hear it. And I'm not tone deaf D:
CowShark 2012년 12월 4일 오후 10시 34분 
Not having listened to the NES metroid music in many years, and not looking at the PRIME on the lower video, I thought the comparison was going to be between the posted Superbrothers song and the original NES title screen. Weirdly, I think it's similar to both, but plagariazes neither. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M-U3sVX2G3w
Largestill 2013년 1월 19일 오전 10시 42분 
I don't hear it. I am norally pretty good that these things.
Murasame72 2013년 2월 17일 오전 1시 15분 
Absolutely not a case of plagiarism. Both track feature common sounds and a somewhat similar mood but that's all ...
BleikurHestur 2013년 7월 21일 오후 2시 15분 
PUT DISPENTRY HERE님이 먼저 게시:
Pineapple님이 먼저 게시:
It's either a nod to Metroid, or just a coincidence. I'd say the first is more likely. I can see a lot of indie developers slipping in references to classic games. I wouldn't rule out the second, though. They do sound alike, especially at the little melody parts

I agree, i'm pretty sure that Jim Guthrie made a reference to the Metroid song. Btw, there are some other big references to Zelda series in the game.

I'm not sure if this is in the game or not, but I was looking through the S&S .DAT files and I found a file named "link," and surely enough it was a S&S version of Link. Either I missed the in-game tribute, or I found something fancy.
BleikurHestur님이 마지막으로 수정; 2013년 7월 21일 오후 2시 15분
Elciled 2013년 7월 22일 오전 6시 54분 
Who cares, the game has Twin Peaks references, that's just too awesome my mind explodes
MithranArkanere 2013년 7월 22일 오전 10시 37분 
Everything is a remix.[everythingisaremix.info]
MithranArkanere님이 마지막으로 수정; 2013년 7월 22일 오전 10시 38분
daseril 2013년 7월 23일 오후 6시 36분 
whether or not it is a tribute, it still sounds cool.
15개 중 1-15 표시중
< >
페이지당: 15 30 50